California Results: Good But Not Great
All eyes were on California yesterday. First the good news:
- Governor: Phil Angelides won the Democratic primary despite a $35 million onslaught from Steve Westly, but the race was highly negative and drove Democratic turnout down - which probably hurt Francine Busby in CA-50. We need the most popular Democrats in the country - Bill Clinton, Al Gore, Barack Obama, and Howard Dean - to join California Democrats in a unity dinner with Steve Westly so we can turn out a strong Democratic vote in November to beat Schwarzenegger and win the crucial House races.
- Secretary of State: Debra Bowen won the primary 60%-40% by promising verified voting. We must make sure she wins in November so she can play a crucial role both in California and nationwide in fighting corrupt electronic voting machine vendors.
- CA-04: Charles Brown won the primary to take on John Doolittle, who had a tough primary.
- CA-06: Progressive Caucus co-chair Lynn Woolsey beat her conservative primary opponent by 2:1.
- CA-11: Jerry McNerney won the primary to take on anti-environmental leader Richard Pombo, who got only 62% in his primary against a moderate. If McNerney can win those moderate votes, he has a good shot at winning.
- CA-26: Cynthia Rodriguez Matthews won the primary to take on closeted gay hypocrite David Dreier.
- CA-51: Bob Filner won his primary with 55% and will continue his progressive leadership in Congress.
But otherwise there were no suprises:
- CA-36: Progressive activist Marcy Winograd ran a fabulous primary against pro-war and pro-wiretapping Jane Harman, but lost 62%-38%.
- CA-50: Francine Busby lost the special election in this solidly Republican district to Brian Bilbray by 49%-45%. Busby will get another chance to beat Bilbray in November.
The Busby-Bilbray race was the one Washington insiders were watching most closely, looking for early signs of a Democratic tsunami in November in the wake of the Duke Cunningham scandal. Republicans spent a whopping $4.5 million to turn out 60,000 votes in a district that cast 170,000 votes for George Bush in 2004. Busby gained 18 points from her 22-point defeat in 2004. Still, Busby might have scored a huge upset if she had not carelessly accepted the help of undocumented volunteers at the very end of the campaign - an issue that was caught on tape and used by rightwing talk show hosts in the final days of the campaign to mobilize the rightwing base. Here's Chris Bowers:
In 2004, Busby lost the CA-50 by 22.0%. Today, it looks like she will lose by around 4.5%. And that was with the NRCC spending $4.5M on the race. If Republicans want to spin losing 18 points after spending $4.5M of committee money as a good thing, go for it. After all, spin is basically why they spent so much money on this race. By blowing their wad in a solidly Republican district, they wanted to change the media narrative on the election in their favor. It will probably work, given how subservient and generally inaccurate the media tends to be when it comes to Republicans and elections. In reality, for a Republican candidate to pull 49.5% of the vote in a district with 44.5% Republican registration is shocking. Given those numbers, Bilbray probably managed all of 20% of the vote among independents.
No matter what the media says, no Democrat should be mistaken about this result. First, this is a huge, seismic shift in our favor that bodes extremely well for November. If we receive an 18% shift nationwide, we will win the House easily. If Republican candidates are pulling only 20% of the independent vote, the Indycrat realignment is still on.
At the same time, this is not as good as we could have done. The situation for Republicans is so bad right now, that even our huge leads in the generic ballot hide what Paul Rosenberg pointed out: we should be doing better. Just because we are winning does not mean we are using winning strategies. Our ten-point advantage in the generic ballot should be fifteen. The eighteen point shift we saw in CA-50 should have been twenty-five. Bilbray will win with under 50% of the vote, and there was low turnout relative to past California primaries. Clearly, there was an opportunity for us to do more.
We had some real victories tonight, and we still have time to rectify our mistakes. Fortunately, come November, even Busby will have another chance. I just hope that as a party we realize that there are clearly better strategic paths for us to take than the ones we are currently following. Tonight, as David Sirota writes, Jon Tester showed us just such a path.
I won't pretend to have all of the answers at 3:30 am. Things are going pretty well, but they could be going even better.
- Bob Fertik's blog
- Login or register to post comments
Printer-friendly version- Send to friend










What stands out in my mind, after listening to Bernie...
Ward and Ray Taliaferro on KGO San Francisco, is that turnout was really poor. The little bits and pieces I'm hearing about[California primary]shows a turnout in the low 30's.
California had a real mix of voting mediums: black boxes, absentee, paper ballots[some of which were not available at the opening of the polling places], some polling places opened up to 3 hours late because voting inspectors didnt show up on time...and much more.
I wish more states would look again at Orygun's vote by mail.
The key for November will be turnout. If we can't get our people to the polls, all the effort/money/time will go for nothing.
A mind once expanded can never return to its original dimensions.
Anne Hathaway: 1556-1623
The greatest derangement of the mind is to believe in something because one wishes it to be so.
Louis Pasteur
It is hard to believe
the mess that we have allowed to happen to our voting system.
Because we have black boxes and it is after all Florida, I thought about voting absentee, then I discovered that in my state absentee ballets aren't counted unless the vote is too close to call without them. There is no way that I have any faith in the machines. Harris helped to sneak through a law that Florida can NOT have a paper trail for those boxes. It looks pretty fishy, don't you think?
There is a lot more going on in this state that stinks, such as election officials having the authority or taking it, to pretty much deal with and count paper ballots any way they wish.
Now that the media has agreed with the powers that be to stop doing exit polls I don't think we will have a leg to stand on, if we question the validity of election results over the next few years. It is very discouraging.
We got the vote out in 2000 and it did little good. The felon rolls are still dishonest and new state law makes it very difficult to get off the list. In effect one has to prove they are innocent, the state doesn't have to prove their case, that you are a felon. No one was even reprimanded for putting up police road blocks in areas where the poor would travel to get to the polls. Police claimed that was just routine license and registration checks and had nothing to do with elections. I could blame it on the south, but I think Ohio proves that corruption has no state borders.
In a time of deception telling the truth is a revolutionary act. ~ George Orwell
Di, I'm afraid Ohio is close
Di, I'm afraid Ohio is close to matching your state in " THIS stinks" by "this STINKS".
I'll raise you one Ken Blackwell...
US Media Sinks to New Low on Tues Races
You know that the US media has sunk to a new low when to get the relevant details of an American political race, you have to go to a news service in Switzerland! The headlines this morning on AOL, CNN, et al. and accompanying stories all made it seem as if the results of Tuesday’s 8 races, all but one of them primaries, were a landmark victory for the GOP, somehow “proving” that the anti-Bush mood in the country doesn’t go all that far. But to make the story come out this way, the “journalists” had to leave out some pretty important “details.”
The story that was pushed to top billing was that Republican Brian Bilray won his bid for disgraced Congressman “Duke” Cunningham’s House seat in a special election. However, the little “details” left out of many US media versions of this story – like this one from ABC - is that the contested district is in one of the nation’s most conservative. In fact, it is the area north of San Diego – yep, that’s right, home to many major military facilities, including Camp Pendleton. Home to many extremely wealthy rightwingers as well. The BIG story here was that Bilray only narrowly defeated Democratic challenger Francine Busby – a FEMALE LIBERAL coming that close to victory over a CONSERVATIVE MALE in this district is big news indeed. Especially as you know damn well that the GOP heavyhitters (including the military brass) were leaning very heavily on all the "party faithful" to turn out and vote. The fact that Busby still did so well is athe real story. Yet ABC’s headline proclaims “Republican wins Bellwether House Race.” Bellwether meaning that the race is somehow a weathervane of the whole nation! Yeah, right. Camp Pendleton and a super-wealthy rightwing suburb really reflect the nation as a whole. Right.
Another core story fluffed over by the media was that Judge Roy Moore – the religious zealot who garnered a vast amount of publicity over the 10 commandments flap – was soundly trounced in his primary challenge of Alabama Gov. Bob Riley. This is a significant story because it shows just how little influence the Christian right really has, even in the Deep South – and even with a challenger who has been given huge amounts of publicity by both the mainstream media and rightwing blogoradiosphere.
The most disturbing thing to me is what the media’s handling of Tuesday’s events signals for the coming November election. This may have been just the first salvo in an all out propaganda war on behalf of the GOP – and against the American people.
Compare the Swiss news story http://www.swissinfo.org/eng/international/ticker/detail/US_House_race_a...
to ABC:
http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wireStory?id=2047867
We must do better
in policing these elections and getting out the vote or the Repugs will steal another election in November. The situation here in Florida is absolutely ridiculous as there is ABSOLUTELY NO WAY for us to have a fair election. If this keeps up, we may be forced to HIT THE STREETS and BREAK the LAW to end the stranglehold Jebby and Co. have on our political process!
Also, I don't care WHAT HE SAYS or ANYONE ELSE SAYS about l'il bro. He's going to be on the Repug ticket in 2008, either as President or VP nominee.(I think it'll be the latter.)
When does this SHIT end?
I voted absentee ballot
I voted using an absentee ballot. Its seems the smart thing to do, however, then you read somewhere, where a bunch of thugs, picked up a bunch of opened democratic ballots, took them out to a trash site, and burned them in a huge container. I hope that kind of corruption doesn't happen in California. If it does, I hope they catch the SOBs involve and cut them a thousand times with their own ballot chads and then use lemon and salt on the wounds.