The Myth of McCain as Political Maverick

  • Bob Geiger's picture
    Bob Geiger
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

David Ignatius has a positively silly column in the Washington Post today in which he parrots the lame old myth of 2008 presidential hopeful John McCain as a straight-talking, tough-guy maverick who damns political consequences and goes his own way. As a Veteran with boundless admiration for McCain's heroic conduct during his imprisonment in Vietnam, I must also evaluate his career incarnation which, if you examine his record, shows him to be a 98-pound political weakling, who does best when others tell him what to do.

Even putting aside his nauseating and ongoing devotion to the White House after what Team Bush did to smear him, his wife and his child in the 2000 presidential primary, McCain's Senate record shows a man who toes the party line and is a straight-shooting nonconformist only when George W. Bush, Dick Cheney and Bill Frist tell him he's allowed to be.

The biggest disconnect from reality comes in the public perception of McCain as a potential president whose strong suit would be national security, even though his record in the 109th Congress shows a man who follows the Senate Majority Leader's commands, no matter how much weaker those edicts make our country.

Here are just a few samples of the things McCain voted against in 2005 and 2006, while offering no substantive legislation himself to strengthen America:

  • Senator Daniel Akaka's (D-HI) S.Amdt. 3007, which was intended to increase Veterans medical services funding by $1.5 billion in 2007 by closing corporate tax loopholes.
  • Three bills by Senator Debbie Stabenow (D-MI) -- S.Amdt. 3056, S.Amdt. 1687 and S.Amdt. 1217 -- that would have provided critical funds for interoperable communications equipment for emergency first responders so that they could effectively communicate with one another during natural disasters, terrorist attacks and other public safety situations.
  • Christopher Dodd's (D-CT) S.Amdt.2735, which was intended to “…support the health needs of our veterans and military personnel and reduce the deficit by making tax rates fairer for all Americans.” In short, the measure proposed additional funding to shore up the failing infrastructures at Veterans hospitals all over the country. The bill would have mandated a minor rollback in the capital gains tax cuts the Bush administration has given to the richest one-fifth of one percent of Americans.
  • S.Amdt.2737, sponsored by Jack Reed (D-RI) sought a rollback in capital gains tax cuts to purchase much-needed equipment for troops serving in Iraq and Afghanistan. “We have the responsibility to be responsible, not only give the troops what they need but pay for it so we do not increase the deficit,” argued Reed on the Senate floor at the time. “I hope we respond by supporting my amendment which takes care of the troops but does so in a responsible way by providing the resources to pay for this necessary equipment.”
  • Charles Schumer (D-NY) had two amendment defeated by the GOP (S.Amdt. 1189 and S.Amdt. 1190) that would have provided $70 million to identify and track hazardous materials shipments and fund new security programs for inspection of air cargo containers.
  • S.Amdt. 16, by Dick Durbin (D-IL), would have exempted military people from some facets of the GOP's hideous 2005 Bankruptcy Bill by disallowing "… certain claims by lenders charging usurious interest rates to service members, and to allow service members to exempt property based on the law of the State of their premilitary residence."
  • Senators Barbara Boxer (D-CA) and Patty Murray (D-WA) both had legislation killed -- S.Amdt. 2634 and S.Amdt. 344, respectively -- that would have funded additional medical care and readjustment counseling "…for [Iraq] veterans with mental illness, post-traumatic stress disorder, or substance use disorder."

The common denominator in all of these was McCain, the alleged maverick, doing exactly what his masters told him to do and voting against every single one of these bills designed to bolster our national security and care for our Veterans and active military.

As McCain himself is quoted as saying in Ignatius's column, "It's awfully hard to say no to the president of the United States."

Yes, we can tell.

You can reach Bob Geiger at



  • Jim's picture
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

Thanks Bob,

It is time to get on this subject.

I was sucked in by McCain for a while there too, but he betrayed descent rational thinking folks over and over again during these Bush years.


John McCain should be

  • antibush23's picture
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

John McCain should be ashamed of himself supporting this clown.

What a great bumper sticker

  • dinamic's picture
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

What a great bumper sticker that would make, Jim, I like it;)

Proud member of the reality based community.

That picture

  • dinamic's picture
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

is really worth a thousand words. It makes nauseatingly clear what a pleaser and a todie to authority and to his party McCain really is. After what bush and the party did to him and to his family his loyalty is still with them over his own best interests and those of his family. How can the Ameircan people trust a man like that? If one looks at the expression on his face and the closed eyes and his general posture in that picture it says everything that needs to be said about who he really is. I truly believe that McCain has something akin to an extreme case of Stockholm Syndrome.

But where is the straight talk today? In gearing up for his run for President in 2008, McCain told Falwell that he spoke "in haste," and has accepted an invitation to give the commencement speech a Farwell's radical Christian college, Liberty University.

It seems that McCain seems to have set out to become the darling of the radical religious right, and has given up on his straight talk. For instance, after sharply denouncing a federal constitutional ban on gay marriage in 2004, he recently told Falwell that he would support a federal constitutional amendment defining marriage as the union of one man and one woman. McCain has also set out to pass voucher legislation that would allow taxpayer money to be spent on religious schools. And to the delight of religious extremists, he said he would have signed the recently enacted abortion ban in South Dakota were he the governor, even though there are no protections for the life of the mother.
Senator John McCain has prided himself on being a "straight talker." In his presidential run in 2000 he called his campaign the Straight Talk Express, and now he has a Political Action Committee named Straight Talk America. It was this "straight talk" that lead him to denounced right-wing extremist Jerry Falwell as one of America's "agents of intolerance."

Proud member of the reality based community.

That Picture.....caption this

  • wahoo's picture
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

Submarine   USS Wahoo  ss238

"What are you doing tonight George, is Laura still out of town?"

Bad, Wahoo

  • Haruka's picture
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

That is a VERY naughty thing to say, Wahoo. Funny as anything, but naughty. LOL