Videodroming on "Life on Mars" with Harvey Keitel

This entry is part of my "Videodroming Project," which you can read about here. Basically, it is to record my impressions of entertainment media that I watch...with a view especially to semiotics -- or how entertainment programming and commercials draw on the social and political issues of the day. So Wednesday night I flipped on "Life on Mars," not knowing anything about it. I was pleasantly surprised to find that it had a first-rate supporting cast: Michael Imperioli (of "The Sopranos"), Gretchen Mol and the one-and-only Harvey Keitel. Basically, it is about a man who is from the present day, but has been magically transported back to 1973, where he works as a detective in an NYC precinct under Keitel, with Imperioli and Mol as his cops-in-arms.

The main thrust of the show is that he is trying to find a way to return to his own time (obviously this "fish out of water" tale has been done many times before -- Irwin Allen's '60's show "Time Tunnel" is the one that springs to my mind, not to mention certain "Star Trek" episodes such as "City on the Edge of Forever" -- and "A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court"). In any case, this allows the show to offer up some compare/contrast between then and now -- in a social and political sense (e.g. cops using walkie talkies instead of cellphones). I really liked the overall style of the show -- it had the look of '70's crime movies -- such as "The French Connection" and "Fingers" with Keitel. It also had a soundtrack like the cop shows of that period -- with the "bow chika bow bow" wah-wah guitar. Some of the look, and the antics in the precinct, reminded me of the first "Hill St. Blues" episode (1981), that I saw recently on DVD (a brawl broke out like those that happened regularly on "HSB," with someone jumping on a character's back, like Belker used to do). But "Life on Mars" also features contemporary film techniques like the swishpans and quick cuts of "NYPD Blue."

The plot of this episode was bit flimsy -- it involved a NYC Councilman who, like the show's protagonist, had been transported from the present. He had found a way to get back to 2009, but was killed before he could make the journey home. The fact that he was a Councilman helped accentuate certain political themes. At one point, he told a character, "The future is not like today -- there is hope." Hmmmm.....many would argue that 1973 looks pretty damned rosy compared to now. But maybe he meant it in the sense of the crime-ridden NYC of the '70's vs. today's Big Apple? But I found this to be a highly facile way of describing "the future" by parroting the mantra of the Obama campaign.At one point, the lead character was quizzing him on events since 1973, to find out if he was for real. The Councilman said, "We have a black President." The lead replied almost incredulously, "Wait -- he won?" (Presumably, he was zapped back to '73 before the election). Later, in a hallucinatory sequence, video images of Obama flashed on the 1973 TV screens behind the lead. A dream-like voice intoned, "This is not your time yet. Your time will come."

In any event, the Councilman had been a crusading liberal (from the future), fighting for the minimum wage and gun control. It was for this that he got killed. At one point, one of the characters said, "It's thanks to his re-zoning that my business was closed down." (Echoes of common woes of today -- losing a business, house, job etc...albeit this character's woes had to do with a politician's actions rather than economics). Also in the show, there was a subplot around Women's lib, as Imperioli's character took issue with Gretchen Mol being a policewoman -- and in some of the feminist views she shared with his wife, whom he obviously wanted to stay at home in a more...ahem...traditional role.

One of the guest characters of this episode was a black prostitute with a bleached-golden afro -- very much like the characters from blaxploitation films and cop shows of the period, such as "Baretta." She played sort of a mystical role in this episode, since during the hallucinatory sequences, she was telling the lead character certain things pertaining to his time-space dilemma. During these sequences, "Over the Rainbow" sung by Judy Garland would play -- and I think the prostitute said, "Click your heels and you can go home." I instantly thought of Diana Ross as Dorothy in "The Wiz." There was also a stereotypical character of a Chinese waiter delivering food to the Precinct.

To go with the Wizard of Oz motif -- it turned out that the man who had the secret for returning the Councilman back to the present was a white-haired sorcerer figure with a cane featuring a rabbit's head ("Alice" anyone?)

The show had another subplot revolving around familial themes -- in this case it was about the conflict between Keitel and his daughter. Echoing this and the Women's Lib subplot of Imperioli's wife was when Keitel suspected an inside job within the Precinct in the murder of the Councilman. He said, "There is no greater betrayal than when it's one of your own family." In the show's climax, Keitel's daughter was held at knifepoint as a hostage by the killer, with Keitel talking him out of it. Again, this was playing on recurring themes I have noticed since starting the "Videodroming" project -- that being threats to the family unit (and the American family specifically). I noticed this especially when I was watching "My Own Worst Enemy" with Christian Slater. The show has been cancelled, but I may share my notes on it at some point.

During the commercial break, there was a spot for "Grey's Anatomy" about the next episode featuring the saving of babies. Again, this is one of the major themes I keep noticing popping up on television. I will write about the commercials that played during this hour in my next blog entry. One last thing, I loved that "Life on Mars" opened with "Ballroom Blitz" by Sweet (one of my all-time fav bands -- keep in mind that my tastes range from the current sounds to Classical, which I have just really been exploring lately). Neverthless, "Ballroom Blitz" is my least favorite of Sweet's hits -- their other famous song, "Fox on the Run" -- is what I call the greatest pop-rock song of all-time, if I had to vote for one. (For just sheer hard rock -- I call Led Zeppelin's "Achilles Last Stand" the greatest). But I digress...

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Good stuff Max. Many people

Good stuff Max. Many people miss the "art reflects life" subtleties embedded in what we watch in the search for mindless escapism.

On the other hand, the "reality show" genre that sprang to life during the Dubya era wasn't burdened with the duty to stimulate our thinking -- it was just a way to tune out the actual reality of our decaying free society.

Thanks Bill! I have watched

Thanks Bill! I have watched almost no television since the Networks basically almost encouraged Bush's theft of the election in 2000. For some months, a friend stayed with me -- who watched "ER." I got hooked into that show. I really bought into the whole nighttime soap opera thing. The characters became very important to me -- throughout the rest of the week until the next episode. I really got the point "Adbusters" once used as a tagline for "National Turn-off your TV Day" -- lose the fantasy. It really can become a fantasy world, esp. if one is a fan of a show.

As for the reality shows -- I have yet to watch those (except fleetingly, at other's houses) -- but I will. One thing is that it might be about how "just plain folks" (albeit some with special talents) can become stars -- like the fantasy of winning the lottery. And of course, it short circuits a lot of the creativity of shows like "Life on Mars," which I admire for many of its retro sensibilities.

I added something in the above about how the mention of hope being in "the future" was a quite simplistic, shallow way of describing today -- by parroting the Obama campaign mantra. I really want to do something different here. Again, I'm not trying to develop any theories or whatever -- I'm just recording my impressions -- which will hopefully encourage others to think about their impressions. Do they coincide with mine? Do they differ? What really counts is how it affects each viewer individually, regardless of where its coming from -- what was the intention of the creators/producers/advertisers. As far as I know, no one is doing this -- and I'm always up for breaking new ground.

I should say that while LoM

I should say that while LoM is a damn site more creative than a reality show ... it is an example of the US Networks "remake-a-successful-series-from-another-country syndrome." The original was made for the BBC.

I lived overseas for a few

I lived overseas for a few years, and became a total fan of many BBC-produced shows. They were certainly way ahead of the USA in dealing with social issues: Steptoe & Son (Sanford & Son), Rising Damp, Monty Python, Benny Hill, Waiting for God, and many more.

I hear you. I think "All the

I hear you. I think "All the Family" was the first big US remake of a BBC show.

Life on Mars did use some

Life on Mars did use some cliches -- the subplot of Keitel and his conflict with his daughter hinged on the old saw about "you only told me you loved me once, Daddy." And of course, the daughter being held at knifepoint was another cliche. Likewise, the whole Women Lib's theme -- Gretchen Mol encouraging Imperioli's wife to cut her hair like hers (liberation -- cut hair subbing for no-bra). Mostly, there was a lot of old, cliched dialogue. Imperioli something about women in the workplace being the "end of civilization." The flip side of that -- dual incomes were not as necessary for most back in 1973.

Coincidentally, I had just

Coincidentally, I had just watched "Pulp Fiction" a few days before. Keitel nearly walks off with that film -- but it's still Samuel L. Jackon's. What a towering performance. I was a little annoyed by the scene in Jack Rabbit Slim's featuring the famous dance (Tarantino's inspiration for that is the cafe dance scene in Godard's "Band of Outsiders." Now that scene is one of the best things I've ever seen in a movie). What bothered me about the diner scene was that it had all the most obvious pop-culture icons -- Elvis, Marilyn, Buddy Holly (probably James Dean was in there too). It's like -- hey --- can't we have some new icons for a change? (Although the "Douglas Sirk" burger was a nice touch. Sirk is one of Tarantino's fav filmmakers. We watched "All that Heaven Allows" in my UCLA film class in the '80's. Great film. A direct line from Sirk and esp. that one to Fassbinder ("All that Heaven Allows) to Todd Haynes' "Far from Heaven" with Julianne Moore and Dennis Quaid.

But then I realized something ... in the midst of all these retro-icons ... Tarantino created a brand new pop culture icon...that of the dance between Travolta (slyly nodding to his major role in "Saturday Night Fever") and Uma (don't say "Uma-Oprah" Letterman!) Thurman. How brilliant.

Correction -- the Fassbinder

Correction -- the Fassbinder film was "Ali: Fear Eats the Soul" which we watched back-to-back with "All that Heaven Allows." In the '50's Sirk soap-opera with Rock Hudson and Jane Wyman -- her kids give her a TV to forget about her love for Rock. In Fassbinder's film set in '70's Germany, the heroine's son kicks in the TV set when he learns about her affair with a young Turk (literally he is Turkish). Can the intertextuality get any plainer. IMDB has a link for movie connections. But I'm very good at catching them myself, and some that IMDB misses. My film class in doing close analyes of films was on cinema from 1945 to the '80's. The prof was Robert Rossen who is the key man behind UCLA's world class archives and film restoration. He is now Dean of UCLA's film school. It was from that class that I learned how to analyze film. The subject of semiotics I picked up from reading UCLA prof Jack Solomon's "The Signs of Our Times." Of course, analyzing news, with a view towards biases and propaganda, first on my own, then for years for Democrats.com played a big part. I was the editor of the daily and weekly newsletter for Dems.com. It was really just me, Bob Fertik and Cheryl Seal posting news items for all those years. I posted probably an average of 10 news items a day on the old Dems.com site (anonymously). I've written only a few articles under my name. Of course, this is a pseud...one of the main reasons is it is from James Wood's character in Cronenberg's "Videodrome."

Another thing...I had not

Another thing...I had not seen "Pulp Fiction" in well over ten years. It is a great film -- not one of my favorites -- but certainly one of best of the '90's. Interesting to see Keitel in such a daring, orginal, code-breaking work just before seeing him in the heavily cliched "Life on Mars." Before PF I saw the Coen bros. "Miller's Crossing" for the first time in almost two decades. While that was a much more highly crafted film -- I think PF is much better. "Miller's Crossing" just didn't hold my interest. On top of that, it was really hard to understand what they were saying in their gangster-ese with their accents. In another film, like Guy Ritchie's "Snatch" I cared enough to figure it out and pay attention, but with MC -- I simply didn't. Still some great sequences, amazing cinematography and very unusual characters. I also saw the Steven Soderbergh remake of "Solaris" with George Clooney. I love the original Tarkovsky film -- it is one of the 30 or so runners-up for my Top Ten. But I think Soderbergh's film stands on its own. It is a good film. He did write his own screenplay from the Stanislaw Lem novel (I read that Lem was not happy with Tarkovsky's film). But Soderbergh's film keeps a lot of the spirit of Tarkovsky's. The somber -- greenish look, the long takes, the de-emphasis on special effects. It certainly also echoes a lot of shots from "2001" (a film Tarkovsky did not like, and which he make "Solaris" partly in reaction to. "2001" is number 2 on my top Ten, after "Vertigo" and before "Lawrence of Arabia," btw). SPOILER ALERT: The only thing I didn't like about the new "Solaris" was the warm fuzzy ending -- which was wildly at odds with the weird, spooky, mystical ending of the original.

I miss your political and

I miss your political and news contributions to Dems.com, but I applaud your new project, and wish you the very best.

Thinking back on the BBC shows that were re-made for American audiences, the one thing I noticed that they had in common (on both sides of the Atlantic) was the empathy of the cast. They seemed to mesh perfectly, and had all of the qualities of a well-tuned repertory company.

Well thanks...you're too

Well thanks...you're too kind. I am thinking that I may try to do a news roundup blog, hopefully on a regular basis. Mostly just article excerpts with ellipses in blurbs, and only jump in with my own views when I feel really impassioned (usually enraged) about something. But I have always strived to be intellectually honest...to check my sources carefully...and to try to give people more reality. I did my damndest for years to try to smash through the propaganda and spin. I totally agree with what the late, great columnist Lars Erik-Nelson once said, "The problem isn't liberalism. The problem isn't conservatism. The problem is bullshit."

Too true Max, and the only

Too true Max, and the only thing that I would add to that is, the "neos" on both sides have it exactly bass-ackwards. They are cut from the same corporate-fawning cloth, and their "bullshit" is virtually indistinguishable.

Well, this really goes back

Well, this really goes back to the Yankee-Cowboy War that Dan Brandt at namebase.org (I think it is wrote about). The "yankee" neo-liberals of the Rockefeller/Eastern Establishment vs. the NeoCons/New Right that were created to counter them. I think that as an institutionalized presence -- the later are the greater threat -- mainly because they have worked so hard to win "the war on Ideas" and create "alternate realities" -- Heritage Foundation, AEI/PNAC, CATO,Murdoch/Fox, Moon, Clear Channel, Limbaugh....etc, etc...

I was thinking more along

I was thinking more along the lines of Will Marshall and Al From, and their "New Democrat" movement. You remember Will, a signatory to the PNAC obscenity, and founder of the Progressive Policy Institute (PPI).

The PPI gained life from the neoliberal "centrist" DLC, which gave dubious credibility to the likes of Joe Lieberman who, along with John McCain, wrote their own pre-PNAC plea for intervention in the ME, and the toppling of Saddam.

Oh, those guys... I don't

Oh, those guys... I don't think of them as the neo-liberals, but as the New Democrats...the centrists...triangulators...wankers...whatever you want to call them. I posted a blog earlier under Ted (rhymes with "Rall) about how one of the big New Right backers gave dough to the DLC. I think it was the Koch family. I think of the Neo-liberals as being more of those from the Council on Foreign Relations -- Rockefeller and Carnegie Foundation think tanks. But maybe I don't have my nomenclature straight???

These new wankers are

These new wankers are calling themselves "neoliberal," but their views seem to be no different than those of the neoconservatives:

http://www.nndb.com/group/269/000093987/

And they align themselves with "The Third Way," their umbrella funding group:

http://www.thirdway.org/

I will often append comments

I will often append comments as continuations of my opening post. I just realized that the main theme of the show "returning home"..."to the time and place where one belongs" is really of the same flavor as the themes around family. All of these themes I see played out constantly in the entertainment media. And there is also the theme of the-loner-as-a-danger-to-society that pops up often too. Being alone...not being part of a family unit...a social circle,etc is more often than not portrayed as being strange rather than being individual or non-conformist. The kind of individuality TV promotes is more in the sense of ... express your individuality with our products...your preferred color of our IMac, etc.

Hmmm...I posted another

Hmmm...I posted another comment that vanished. Could be I thought it was a duplicate post (so I zapped it) ...when it wasn't. This is more or less what I wrote. Movies like "Wizard of Oz" and shows like "HR PufnStuf" always kind of bummed me out -- 'cause it was about a kid being separated from his family. Even if it was an adult where this was the situation -- it also was a downer for me...no matter how magical the land, or wondrous the adventures. I thought "Rip Van Winkle" was the saddest story on Earth when I was a kid...man sleeps his entire life, and his kids don't know him. I love "The 5000 Fingers of Dr. T" which was the first live-action Dr. Seuss film (with a script by Seuss, produced by Stanley Kramer, with Hans Conreid) -- but still very much like "the Wizard of Oz." Great children's fantasy though that adults can enjoy. Still somewhat obscure and underappreciated. The only movie like these that didn't bum me out was "Time Bandits" which I saw recently, 'cause the parents were such annoying, boring drips and the Bandits and the lands they went to were so great.

Max, I enjoy 'Life on Mars'

and watch it every week, with few exceptions.

The cast is top notch, the plot is VERY interesting,
and the scenery/music is straight from 1973.

I have a tendency to dissect plots and find this
show gets more interesting as you peel off each
layer.

Thanks for sharing this. I hope more people
tune in to it now.

Well, thank you. I think the

Well, thank you. I think the show has many virtues, esp. for it's attempt to capture not just the period, but even the look of movies from the '70's. Feel free to add your own thoughts about this and other shows. I really want to get a dialogue started -- with the emphasis being on what each of us as viewers experiences watching it. What impressions are we getting, esp. in terms of politics and social values. My favorite (sarcasm) are the car commercials that preach aphorisms about life, hard work, responsibility, success, etc. like something out of the "Seven Habits of Highly Effective People." More on that later.

Max, glad you mentioned Tarentino...

really like his stuff...he just gets better and better. New movie by him in the works but not yet released. Thought the two Kill Bill dvds were super and the soundtrack outstanding.

A mind once expanded can never return to its original dimensions.

Anne Hathaway: 1556-1623

 

The greatest derangement of the mind is to believe in something because one wishes it to be so.

Yes Grinch, I like Tarantino

Yes Grinch, I like Tarantino quite a lot, too. One of the things I like best about him is his broad taste in films -- in seeing the value in many exploitation film. Had it not been for reading his interviews, and seeing some of the films he re-released under his "Rolling Thunder Pictures" label, I would have never given these films a chance. He also opened my mind to a lot of international cinema, esp. Japan and Hong Kong. Another thing I like about him is that Brian De Palma is probably his favorite living director. He is almost definitely my fav, too. I saw the Charlie Rose interview Tarantino gave some months about "Pulp Fiction," and most of the time he talked about De Palma. Btw, I was just looking at a fan site about him, where they list many of his favorite films. You can see it here.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.