Morality Amendment to the Constitution

  • Bob Fertik's picture
    Bob Fertik
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

For the past week, I have listened to Republicans and the media credit Bush's "victory" to the religious right, which voted for Bush because their top issue was "morality" - meaning outlawing abortion and homosexuality.

Personally, I don't believe Bush and the Republicans have the slightest interest in outlawing either one. I believe they are simply playing a game of sucker with true-believing evangelicals - promising action they never intend to deliver, so they can keep their "base" fired up election after election. (I've heard Chris Matthews express similar sentiments on Hardball, although he would probably deny it if pressed.) 

Republicans have been playing this game in every election since Roe v. Wade was decided in 1973. After 1980, when Ronald Reagan won on an anti-abortion platform, and brought an anti-abortion Senate in on his coattails, rightwing Senators Orrin Hatch (R-UT) and Jesse Helms (R-NC) actually introduced "Human Life Amendments" to outlaw abortion. In a bizarre twist, they introduced two different versions and never reconciled them, so it never even passed the Republican Senate.

After 30 years of this, I'm sick and tired of this Republican game. So now that Republicans control the White House and Congress - with a mandate to legislate "morality" - I propose the following Morality Amendment to the Constitution.

Abortion shall be treated as murder under the criminal law of every state and territory. Sodomy shall be treated as rape under the criminal law of every state and territory.

Could such an Amendment ever pass? No - because the overwhelming majority of Americans do not support the criminalization of abortion and homosexuality. Here is the exit poll data on abortion:

Always Legal 21%
Mostly Legal 34%
Mostly Illegal 26%
Always Illegal 16%

The Republican position on abortion - always illegal - has the support of 16% of Americans. I believe the 26% who say "mostly illegal" have "fuzzy" views on the issue, and if they were presented with a clear "moral" choice - whether to put millions of women and their doctors in jail - they would overwhelmingly vote against criminalization.

I believe Republican leaders (who are all rich white men) know if they promoted such an amendment, the majority - led by women - would rise up and sweep them into the dustbin of history.

But Republicans believe Bush's razor-thin 51%-49% "victory" is a "mandate" to impose the "morality" of a minority onto the majority.

So I dare the Republicans - and the political "leaders" of the religious right (George Bush, Karl Rove, Ralph Reed, Pat Robertson, Jerry Falwell, and James Dobson) - to stop lip-synching about "morality," and take specific legislative action to put their "morality" into the Constitution.

To put it in language simple enough for Bush and his brainwashed followers to understand: put up or shut up.

I dare you.

Comments

Hear hear

You go Bob!

Our spokesmen should be baiting the GOP leadership...

  • Tim Chambers's picture
    Tim Chambers
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

...to introduce such legislation at every opportunity. We should make their lawmakers squirm and regret they were ever so stupid as to acually appeal to such base instincts in the voters.

It would certainly expose the crazies

Like Mike Huckabee, who wants lots of couples to join him and his wife in a 'covenant' marriage ceremony. Sounds Moonish to me. Anyway, 'covenant' marriage requires that couples jump hurdles before they can divorce. People like Huckabee would vote for an amendment such as you describe, but I think the other republicans (the ones who haven't drank the Flavor Aid, yet) would be smart enough to know that republican women enjoy having their Constitutional protections, too. It's an interesting theory, that we should force the republican nutcases to choose between the extremists and the moderate republicans. I say let's go for it. I think it would be funny as hell, watching as republican legislators were exposed as being a bushel full of cracked nuts. http://www.arkansasnews.com/archive/2004/11/09/News/308349.html http://www.elsewhere.org/rant/koolaid.html

If pure religion is the criterion to denominate candidates, those who make a noise about it must be rejected; for their wrangle about it, proves that they are void of it. ~John Leland, July 5, 1802.

Hell, we shouldn't even exercise the filibuster...

  • Tim Chambers's picture
    Tim Chambers
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

...until our most vital interests are at stake. Give people a good taste of what these wingnuts want to do, with the kind of majorities we'll get we can probably repeal them the very next term, if the courts don't do so first.

Absolutely.

  • Bouldin's picture
    Bouldin
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

Let's let America have a much better taste of what radical government looks like. Judging by the gloating going on at Nazional Review and other wingnut organs, they're more than willing to really show the stuff they're made of. Meanwhile, the repugs have never won an election by talking about their true agenda - let's let them give the electorate a live demonstration, and we'll see what the results are. In 2006, there are 21 repug Senators up for re-election, and we only need 15 seats in the House to retake the majority.

I for one like those numbers.

ain't that the truth

  • trlenhart's picture
    trlenhart
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

You're right, no doubt. I'm sure they know as well as we do that they can't really get any of their morality legislation passed. It's just a ploy to get votes. Don't get me wrong-- I'm sure they would love to see the bills passed, but in the end, they will lack enough support from the left AND from the middle.

Be very afraid

  • vince's picture
    vince
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

I agree with everything you guys are saying, however I think they are going to take the back door route. Check out this link:
http://www.prayeralert.org/alertarchives/alert-040204.html

We've got to be ready for anything!!