Let's Fight for the Medicare Option

  • Bob Fertik's picture
    Bob Fertik
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

January is a crucial month for the progressive movement. We spent most of 2009 fighting for single-payer Medicare for All or, as a compromise, a robust public option. But Joe Lieberman and Ben Nelson blocked both, and now demand our surrender. Will we surrender to LieberCare?

I believe we can fight, but with one caveat: for once, the broad progressive movement must work a bit harder to unite. Democratic leaders will meet this Monday to negotiate a final deal. We can only win this quick fight if we're all working together every day.

I believe the policy that would unite the broadest coalition is a "Medicare Option" - a "public option" that specifically lets Americans under 65 buy into Medicare if they want that choice.

Why "Medicare Option"? For two simple reasons:

  1. An overwhelming 64%-30% majority of Americans support the Medicare Option.
  2. Joe Lieberman himself supported the Medicare Option until he discovered how popular it was.

Of course many progressives have other "bottom lines" we should also fight for as a unified coalition:

  1. Tax the rich, not healthcare - a key issue for unions
  2. Mandate employers, not people - another key issue for unions and civil libertarians
  3. No new restrictions on abortion coverage - a key issue for feminists
  4. Prescription drug importation and negotiated prices - a key issue for patients
  5. State single-payer authorization - the compromise to national single-payer proposed by Rep. Kucinich that passed the House Energy & Commerce Committee with bipartisan support

To succeed, we must unite as much of the progressive movement as possible:

  1. Across the organizational spectrum - blogs, c3's, c4's, unions, PACs, 527's, for-profits
  2. Across the ideological spectrum, from single-payer to public option to universal coverage
  3. Across the tactical spectrum, from DC insiders to street protesters
  4. Across the technological spectrum - bloggers, emailers, Facebookers, Tweeters, texters

As a coalition, we should fight with all the weapons we have:

  1. Persuasive blogging and press outreach
  2. Direct lobbying of Members by DC insiders
  3. Email and phone lobbying by activists across the country
  4. Hard-hitting video ads for Youtube and broadcast
  5. Protests at district offices
  6. Google ads targeting Members

That's my proposal in a nutshell - I welcome your thoughts below.

AttachmentSize
medicareoption.gif6.59 KB

Comments

YES!

  • jamesps's picture
    jamesps
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

Bob, I love all activists equally, but I especially love that you seem more inclined to roll up your sleeves and get to work instead of bicker. THANK YOU for this!

perhaps it's because

  • Bob Fertik's picture
    Bob Fertik
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

i'm 52 and therefore older than most of the bloggers. that makes more impatient for change before (my) time runs out!

Liebercare?

  • World Citizen's picture
    World Citizen
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

As a French teacher, I must confess that I don't know the German language, but I believe that "liebe" means "love." (The song, "Liebestraum," comes to mind -- "Love Song.") So I would not refer to the healthcare recommendations of Joe Lieberman as "Liebercare." It might be more appropriately described as "Hate-NoCare" because his program is "hateful."

I think your Progressive suggestions, Bob, are exactly what we need to be doing. And...I do believe they're realistically "do-able." Where we have a major problem is in our lack of adequate time in our daily lives to do what needs to be done. Apparently the RadCons have lots of time on their hands to do their hateful activism while most of us on the Progressive side are busy working, trying to get our jobs done every day...taking care of our children and ourselves to the best of our ability. We don't have as much time as we need to do the "heavy lifting" that must be done to achieve your recommended actions. However, we (I) will do as much as I can and that will be done principally by phone or by writing (LTEs, messages to "electeds" and friends, etc.).

yes the RadCons seem to have

  • Bob Fertik's picture
    Bob Fertik
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

endless time on their hands, but there are far more of us than of them so if we each take a few actions, our collective impact is huge. thanks for all you do!

rally round the flag pole

  • georip's picture
    georip
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

Very solid thinking in there Bob, I just question whether we can effect change in time before the House and Senate bills are resolved. Expanding medicare is certainly a good idea. Let's not forget the states rights issue of giving states the opportunity for devising their own health care systems. I know Maine has been discussing a plan to copy the Canadian system.

In the case that we fail to achieve our aims, all of the ideas you mention move into strategy planning for the next opportunity to reform healthcare, whether at the state level or, ultimately again, the national level. In the meantime and always, the most significant line in your piece was the following, ".. the broad progressive movement must work a bit harder to unite."

I often refer to the symbolism of the flag pole as being "the central organizing principle around which we agree to unite." I contend that principle is social justice and propose that we would have an easier time uniting if we couch our thinking and discussion in that principle. Labor, health care, education, the environment, global trade, prison reform,..etc. ; these are all social justice issues. We can rally around the flagpole of social justice. The laundry list of social justice issues is long and overwhelming, the important thing to our unity is that we all agree on one thing, social justice itself as motivating our unity.

World Citizen above made an important point, that citizens don't have the time to be as fully informed as necessary and to act upon their eternal vigilance. Also relevant is the willingness, the interest, in being involved. Many, many citizens have the time, but not the interest. Hopefully that is slowly changing. If we were more civilized our citizens would have more time off, the 40 hour week should go to a 35 hour week. But citizens would have to realize that they would have to exert citizen power to make that shift. Citizens won't have power unless they take action to get it. The single most empowering action I am familiar with can be found at www.vote.org

The concepts which we forge into our united effort must be of such universal value that the unity of mankind can be sustained into the distant future.

No global social justice, no peace.

Geo Rip

social justice is definitely

  • Bob Fertik's picture
    Bob Fertik
    Want to meet our members? Click 'Join' above!

the core principle shared by progressives - you're exactly right.

the challenge in political organizing is to win specific battles on individual social justice issues on our very long "laundry list."

we spent most of 2009 fighting for social justice in healthcare, but we didn't win - yet.

we still have a week or two to fight, so i'm hoping progressives will unite on a Medicare Option in time to make a difference.